Control over delegated legislation

Besides this other measures should be taken to strengthen the control of Parliament over delegated legislation. It would examine the delegated legislation to see that it was within the power granted by the act, that it was not retrospective, that it did not unnecessarily diminish personal rights and liberties and that it did not give bureaucrats unreviewable power over the public.

The committee may describe the problems it is having and request the government to table a comprehensive response in the House of Commons within days. Finally, there is no parliamentary system of regular review of existing delegated instruments to see if they are still required, and sunset clauses are very rare.

It can require the delegated legislation to be laid before parliament and that it not come into effect until parliament approves it-either by an affirmative resolution, or by the lapse of a specific period without the legislation having been disallowed. There has been always a need for delegated legislation.

The Senate has no power to amend or to disallow parts of delegated instruments, though it would like the latter power. Most ministers are reasonably cooperative, but the committee does not yet have much political clout.

The Doctrine of Ultra Vires as Judicial Control over Delegated Legislation in India

The Acts of Parliament delegating legislative powers to other bodies or authorities often provide certain procedural requirements to be complied with by such authorities while making rules and regulations, etc.

This is due to the constitutional structurization in that country in which it is considered only the duty of courts to review the legality of administrative rule-making. AIR SC In India The legislative control over administration in parliamentary countries like India is more theoretical than practical.

The power was given in the early days of federation, when the concept was that the lower house represented the people and the Senate represented the states, and it was logical to give the two houses separate powers.

Some of them seem to regard the disallowance of a regulation as almost a vote of no confidence. It has been found that the necessity to make a public report to the House of Commons concentrates the minds of bureaucrats wonderfully.

In modem times the sheer bulk of legislation required to effect the business of government is so great that if the legislative function were performed by Parliament alone, then the law-making machine would become choked and grind to a standstill.

In India, the question of control on rule-making power engaged the attention of the Parliament.

Chapter 9: Parliamentary control of delegated legislation

Benoari Lal Sharma Conditional legislation was again applied by the privy council wherein the validity of an emergency ordinance by the Governor-General of India was challenged inter alia on the ground that it provided for setting up of special criminal courts for particular kinds of offences, but the actual setting up of the courts was left to the Provincial Governments which were authorised to set them up at such time and place as they considered proper.

The criteria for review are generally based on the recommendations of the Donoughmore Committee in Britain, and are adequate, but in none of the assemblies is there is a formal procedure for disallowance of a regulation criticised by the committee.

The notable use of this technique was made in the Reorganization Acts of towhich authorised the President to reorganise the executive government by administrative rule-making.

Effectiveness of Parliamentary Control over Delegated Legislation

Delegated legislation, also referred to as secondary legislation, is legislation made by a person or body other than Parliament. With a view to strengthen Parliamentary control over delegated legislation, Scrutiny Committees were established.

Supra Note 6, at p. Provided the legislative policy is enunciated with sufficient clearness or a standard laid down the courts cannot and should not interfere with the discretion that undoubtedly rests with the legislature itself in determining the extent of delegation necessary in a particular case.

Parliament being supreme and it power to legislate being unlimited, there is nothing to prevent Parliament from delegating its legislative power to the executive officers or other subordinate bodies.

Delegated laws are made by a person or body to whom parliament has expressly delegated part of its law-making power by an act of parliament. It is impossible for anyone to keep abreast of all delegated legislation.

Where the delegating statute itself is ultra vires to the Constitution of India, the rules made under such statute are also unconstitutional.

The prospect of having an instrument disallowed is an excellent spur for a minister.1 Judical Control over Delegated Legislation By Prof (Dr) Mukund Sarda× The Indian Constitution has established a Welfare State1 which mandates that the State shall legislate on innumerable activities.

Control by Parliament: Fairly limited, though Parliament has the initial control with the enabling Act which sets boundaries within which delegated legislation is made. The parliament retains control over delegated legislations as it can repeal the powers in the enabling Act at any time.

The Doctrine of Ultra Vires as Judicial Control over Delegated Legislation in India Article shared by The chief instrument in the hands of the judiciary to control delegated legislation is the “Doctrine of ultra vires.”.

Home Administrative Law Delegated legislation Legislative control of delegated legislation. In England, because of Doctrine of Parliamentary Sovereignty, the control exercised by the Parliament over delegated legislation is very effective.

Position in United States Position in India Related Topics. This essay has been submitted by a law student. This is not an example of the work written by our professional essay writers. Control Over Delegated Legislation. The parliamentary control over delegated legislation should be a living continuity as a constitutional remedy.

The Judicial Control over Delegated Legislation in India

The fact that the delegation of legislative power has become too broad, by this fact, the judicial control has struck, giving way to desirability and necessity of parliamentary control.

Control over delegated legislation
Rated 5/5 based on 91 review